IF YOUR  TOTAL KNEE FAILS


CONTENTS

Why the total knee fails

Psychical suffering

Signs of failed total knee

When is revision operation necessary

Techniques for revision operations

Results of revision operations


1

Why the total knee  fails     

Most total knee replacements produce reliably good function, freedom from pain, and stability of the new total knee joint.

A small minority of total knee joints might fail.  The reasons for failure of a total knee joint are very different, because there are so many  different anatomic structures, such as muscles and ligaments around the total knee, that may fail.

Here follows a short list of possible failure mechanisms of a total knee. It is important to know the precise reason of failure, because only then the surgeon may repair it. The failed total knee may be sometimes rescued without new operation entirely, or with only a minor operation on soft tissues.

Aseptic loosening of the total knee:

Causes pain and stiffness in the total knee. Either the tibial (the lower), or the femoral (the upper) component, or both may become loose. The loosening may usually be seen on X-rays.

Unstable total knee

When you feel that your total knee is not stable, the instability may have several causes: the knee may totter because the side ligaments (collateral ligaments) are flaccid. The knee may buckle backwards because the stretching mechanism (the quadriceps muscle) is weak. A worn out tibial component may   make the side ligaments (collateral ligaments) too long and make the collateral ligaments flaccid.

Unstable patella (kneecap)

causes instability and pain in the total knee.   The patient may feel popping of the kneecap, or even describe a  sudden "dislocation" of the whole joint. The cause is often bad position of the total knee prosthesis, so that kneecap cannot follow the track on the femoral component during bending and stretching of the knee.

Catastrophic wear and breakage of the total knee components

occurs more often in patients with severe deformities in their knees. It may be recognized on the X-ray pictures.

Infection of the total knee

may occur late, months or even years after the operatation wound healed. It causes severe unremitting pain in the total knee. Sometimes there occur small openings in the operation wound scar that produce watery liquid.   Laboratory results show signs of infection, although the values may be only marginally positive. The X-ray pictures show signs of continuing destruction of the skeleton around the total knee components, especially if the infection was ongoing longer period.

Damage (rupture) of the stretching mechanism of the knee

is a very serious complication. Most often it is the rupture of the ligament that connects the kneecap (patella) to the shinbone (tibia). This ligament is prone to rupture in patients with previous knee operations. The kneecap itself may also broke apart if  it is too thin , for example after previous operations.

Stiff total  knee

The main cause of stiff total knee is widespread scarring of the muscle that stretches the knee joint. This occurs more often after repeated previous operations of the knee. But there may be  also scaring of soft tissues around the knee joint caused by the joint disease, such as rheumatoid arthritis.

Fracture of the skeleton around the total knee components

occurs most often just above the upper rim of the (femoral) component of the prosthesis. The causes are poor quality of the bone tissue (osteoporosis), a notch in the skeleton done during implantation of the femoral component, and a forcing movement of the stiff knee.

Some of these fractures heal with immobilization in braces, other need operative treatment.


2

Psychical suffering may be worse than the pain in the failed total knee

So you have  been told by your surgeon that your total knee has failed and that you should have a new operation. This could not be a surprise because your total knee was worrying you for some time. Yet, the message caused a chock. There were perhaps words and terms in your surgeon’s message that you did not understand. You are anguished how all this will end.

Calm down and start to think rationally. Practically all complications of total knee surgery are "treatable", although the success rate of individual treatments may vary.

Try to collect more information:

Why is this new operation of your total knee necessary, what is the complication of your total knee that  needs treatment with a new operation?

What precisely will the surgeon do with your total knee - what kind of new operation your surgeon recommends to you?

What is the postoperative treatment after this new operation?

What are the results of the new operation?

What are the possible risks with the new operation?

Note that the surgeons often speak about "revision operation", meaning that they will "revise" the total knee prosthesis. This   means that the surgeon will look at the state of the total knee components, assess their fixation to the skeleton an possible exchange only the worn polyethylene components or

the surgeon may only tighten the flaccid ligaments.

This are only minor operations.

When the surgeons speak explicitly  about "exchange operation",  they will take the failed total hip prosthesis out and put a new prosthesis in.  This is a large major surgery.

Ask your surgeon what precisely your new operation will be.

 


3

How will I know the failed   total  knee?

The surest sign of a failure of a total knee replacement is increasing and lasting pain in the total knee. A painful total knee which restricts patient’s daily activities severely is a failed total knee. The pain and other symptoms from a failed total knee are lasting and / or increasing. 

There are other signs of failure of a total knee:

increasing stiffness of the knee joint

increased edema (swelling) of the knee

increased  quantity of liquid in the joint

more limping

increased instability of the knee

You must, however, realize that well healed total knee joints may be painful  on occasion,

that many patients feel  sometimes "clunks" and other noises from their total knees, that are well healed

and that in general the function of the total knee joint is not as good as the function of a normal knee joint. These occassional   inconveniences are not  signs of a failed total knee.

 


4

When is a revision operation necessary?

Reasons for a revision operation of a failed total knee are similar to the reasons for the primary total knee operation:

unbearable pain and loss of function of the total knee.

 

What happens if I will not have a new revision operation of my total knee?

It depends on the complication that caused the failure of your total knee. Osteolysis, bone dissolving disease, and deep infection destruct quickly large areas of the skeleton around the total knee. These complications cannot be left untreated.

Loosening of the total knee prosthesis with little changes in the skeleton that do not progress, on the other hand, is usually treated without a new operation initially. The surgeon prescribes restricted weight bearing and  follows the development of skeletal changes on repeated X-ray controls .


5

Techniques for revision operations

Revision operation is aimed at to remove the cause of the total knee failure:

for example, if the main problem is instability of the total knee, the surgeon may tretch the flaccid ligaments, choose to put in a larger total knee prosthesis, or put in a linked total knee prosthesis. (see the chapter Linked total knees)

At revision operation of a total knee failed by loosening   the biggest problem is usually to reconstitute the severe bone loss caused by bone destruction around the failed total knee prosthesis, and restore the stability in the revised total knee.

The surgeon may use special revision total knee prostheses. The revision prostheses must be anchored in the healthy skeleton for their stability. These prostheses are bulkier and have a longer shaft to fill the void after the destructed skeleton.


Impaction grafting

A new technique how to treat the skeleton defects caused by failed total knee prostheses is the use of bone grafts to fill these skeletal defects. The method is called impaction grafting.

The surgeon fills the cavity in the bone left after the failed total knee with small bone chips. The bone chips come from the femoral heads removed at the total hip replacement operations done on other patients. The femoral heads are ground with special grinding machines directly at the operation table and the resulting bone chips are sometimes mixed with antibiotics.

With special instruments, the surgeon impacts the mass of the small bone chips in every cranny of the cavity, so that the solidly packed bone chips make a stable foundation for the placement of the revision prosthesis.

These femoral heads are stored in deep frozen state in special bone banks and used first when the donors (the patients from whom they were taken) are proven to be free from the blood borne infections AIDS and hepatitis.

For revision operations of failed total knees with very large skeletal defects, the small bone chips are not enough. The surgeon may use large pieces of skeleton, for example pieces of femoral shaft bone, to repair the large bone defects. These bone allografts,  coming from corpses, are stored and controlled in special bone banks before the delivery to the surgeon. ( Bone transplants coming from other individuals are called bone allografts.).


Cemented total knees prostheses in revision operations?

The armchair logic mandates the use of only cementless total knee prostheses in revision operations of failed total knee prostheses.

This logic, however,    is not always impeccable. Some studies show that  the results of cemented revision operations  have   equally good results as the cementless revision prostheses.

Ask always your surgeon about his / her personal experience with the new total knee prosthesis he is recommending you.


6

Results of revision operations

are usually inferior to the results of primary total hip replacement operations. The range of motion in the new total knee may be smaller and the walking capacity may be also diminished. The patient satisfaction with a revised total knee, however,  is almost as high as the satisfaction with the first total knee operation.

The results of revision operation depend on the mechanism that caused the failure. Results of revision operation for a loose total knee are usually very good, results of revision operations for infected total knee depend on the severity of the infection.


References:

Vince KG.; J Arthroplasty 2003; 18 Suppl I: 39 - 44

Robertsson O. The Swedish Arthroplasty Register. Thesis, Lund 2000.


BACK to Total Knee Index

NEXT   to Materials for TKR


Before you take any action, please read the DISCLAIMER